The Past, Tessa Hadley, Harper, 2016, 310 pp
Summary from Goodreads: Three adult sisters and
their brother meet up at their grandparents' country home for their
annual family holiday--three long, hot summer weeks. The beloved but
crumbling house is full of memories of their childhood--of when their
mother took them to stay with her parents when she left their
father--but this could be their last summer in the house, now they may
have to sell it. And under the idyllic pastoral surface, there are
tensions.
My Review:
One of the ways I like to nerd out as a reader is to read several novels that basically tell the same story in different ways. Then I compare and contrast in my mind about the various books.
The Past falls into that group of novels in which a family of adult siblings get together in the home where they grew up for a last reunion before that home must be sold. I think we are drawn to such stories because they examine at least three generations, because all families have their quirks and issues, sorrows and joys, and because we can see how the passing of almost one hundred years affects the way life is for each generation.
Literary fiction, by which I mean fiction with skillful writing and deeper thoughts about life than so-called mainstream, commercial, or popular fiction, is my reading preference. I totally get it that it is not for everyone. The Past is highly literary. Set in a small British town, it moves at a slow pace with plenty of description of weather and place as well as a look at the inner lives of the characters. There is however plenty of tension in the story that builds to an unexpected climax.
I liked it. It got me to look again at my own family and the ways in which our shared life unites us while our different personalities create friction. I realized that every family has a sort of myth about itself which is just that; a myth, not the truth.
This year as I was following The Tournament of Books, I became impressed by one of the many people who comment on each day's winners and losers. When the above mentioned person started a new group on Goodreads, I joined. We read and discuss new literary fiction. Our first group read was The Past and that is how I came to read it.
I don't actually enjoy on-line book discussions because they are too disjointed for me. I get worked up about some of the vitriol people express about the book. I much more enjoy book discussions in real life where the dialogue is immediate and we can respond to each other in real time. But I am intrigued by the books this group intends to read.
So I lurk and don't comment often. The group's creator and moderator is conscientious, thoughtful, and kind. That helps. I am glad to have read Tessa Hadley and will probably seek out other novels by her.
Books I have also enjoyed on this theme:
The Green Road, by Anne Enright
Wish You Were Here, by Stewart O'Nan
Can you recommend others I might like?
Do you participate in on-line book discussions? If so, what makes them work for you?
(The Past is available in various formats by order from Once Upon A Time Bookstore.)
That way of looking at a theme written from the perspective of various authors can tell you who did it best, I suppose.
ReplyDeleteI don't participate in online book discussions beyond the comments platform on blogs. I guess that has encapsulated me as a reader/blogger, but I prefer to read what I like rather than what others dictate.
I know. I am obsessed. I think I have achieved a balance between reading what I want and reading for my groups. Don't tell those groups, but I am gently and firmly leading them to read what I want to read-:)
DeleteSome years ago, I tried participating in some of Goodreads groups' online discussions, but I quickly grew frustrated with them and eventually gave it up. Like Carmen, my current online discussions are essentially limited to the various blogs that I follow.
ReplyDeleteI've never really tried reading on a theme. I find that often a book or an article that I read suggests or brings to mind another book or author, and so my mind makes that leap and I put the book/author on my TBR list. Reading on a theme would certainly be a more structured and methodical way of doing things, but I'm afraid I'm just not that organized.
It is not so much that I read on a theme, but like you I notice themes and then do my comparing. If my lists were more methodical instead of just so darn long, would I get more methodical in my reading? Not really sure I want to. If you saw all my lists and scraps of paper etc, you would crack up.
DeleteDear Judy you know me by now...I always read books that I truly fall in love with...chemistry has to operate. By the way, before Sister Carrie I read a gorgeous and fun book "Out of Sorts" by Aurelie Valognes. See you in July ; -)))))
ReplyDeleteVery sweet of you to catch up on all my posts before your trip. Have a good one!
DeleteI often read on themes - it introduces me to books I would never had read otherwise, and can be lots of fun.
ReplyDeleteOn this particular story-line, I know that the The Nest by Cynthia D'Aprix Sweeney is very popular right now.
I agree Debbie on themes leading to books I otherwise might not have read. Good on mentioning The Nest. That is one I have to check out.
DeleteNice post Judy. Various ideas in this one. May I ask which book group is this on Goodreads? I'm just curious about its book list. I haven't tried an online discussion group before. I wonder if it would work for me? I sort of like reading from my own stack. but wouldn't mind trying every once in awhile
ReplyDeleteThe group is called Newest Literary Fiction. For June we are discussing The Queen of the Night by Alexander Chee. As usual, I am behind in my reading plans and have not even started it yet. Ha Ha.
Delete